Weathered cedar-shingle entry with a navy door, white sash windows and sun-bleached porch decking beside an oakleaf hydrangea.

Westhampton Beach Grocery Stores: Where to Shop After Lidl

October 8, 2026

"I think they felt the market really wasn't right for them. It was sort of this upscale vacation market and it didn't fit in with their prototype." Cary Staller said that to Newsday in September. He is president of Staller Associates, the firm representing the landlord at 70 Sunset Avenue. The Lidl in that building is the largest grocery store in the Village of Westhampton Beach at 29,118 square feet. It closes this Sunday, October 11. A Lidl US spokesperson gave that date to The U.S. Sun on October 3 and said the store stays open to customers through that day. Lidl's own store page now says the same thing: "Will be closed permanently 10/11."

Anyone who heard "end of October" in September heard the earlier timeline. That was the date first reported by Newsday and 27east. The retailer has since moved it up by roughly three weeks.

The building has changed grocers four times in about eleven years, and every change left a gap. For now, Westhampton Beach shops a different way. Specialty counters cover the village, the big weekly cart goes to supermarkets down Montauk Highway, and a Saturday market calendar runs straight through to spring.

Four Grocers, One Building

The space at 70 Sunset has a longer track record than most people remember. Pieced together from Newsday and 27east, it goes like this:

  1. Waldbaum's ran the store for years and closed in September 2015, after its parent company, A&P, filed for bankruptcy.
  2. Best Market bought the store in bankruptcy court for $4 million and opened in 2016.
  3. Lidl US bought 27 Best Market stores in 2018, including this one. The Westhampton Beach Best Market closed in November 2020 and reopened as a Lidl the following May.
  4. Lidl's lease ran out in March 2026. Staller said the grocer got an extension into the fall.

Staller also told Newsday that a full-service supermarket will open in the space. He would not name the tenant because of a confidentiality agreement. No opening date has been announced. The U.S. Sun's October 3 update also said the replacement is still undisclosed.

Staller's comments explain the mismatch. Newsday notes that about 80% of Lidl's products are its own private-label brands, and that the format is a limited-assortment grocer, smaller than a traditional supermarket. "It wasn't really what the community wanted, I think," Staller said. Mayor Ralph Urban gave 27east another side of it. He said many residents enjoyed Lidl's produce, its bakery, and its affordability. He also pointed to how hard it is to run a supermarket in a village with a busy summer and a quiet off-season. A letter to 27east from a Speonk resident called the closing a loss and praised the store's prices, bakery, and customer service. Lidl says each Westhampton Beach employee will be offered a job at another Lidl US location.

The Last Weekend Is the Village's Busiest Fall Weekend

The closing lands on the most crowded weekend of the village's fall calendar. Lidl's posted hours for Saturday, October 10 are 8 a.m. to 9 p.m. Here's what else is happening within a few blocks:

Day Event Where Hours
Sat., Oct. 10 Westhampton Beach Farmers Market Village Green 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.
Sat., Oct. 10 Inlet2Inlet beach cleanup Dune Road, Moriches Inlet to Shinnecock Inlet See Inlet2Inlet
Sat., Oct. 10 Inlet2Inlet Fall Fair, rain date Sun., Oct. 11 Great Lawn, 35 Main Street Noon to 5 p.m.
Sun., Oct. 11 Chamber Fall Festival with the New York Vendettas Main Street 11 a.m. to 5 p.m.
Oct. 11 to 13 Main Street sidewalk sales Participating shops 11 a.m. to 5 p.m.

The Westhampton Chamber's festival page lists the sidewalk-sale merchants. They include CALLA, Dae Glo, Diana's Unique Boutique, Island Surf, Mint, Palmer & Purchase, Saltwater Clothing Co. and White's Apothecary. One event listing elsewhere puts the Chamber festival on Saturday. The Chamber's own page says Sunday, and that's the one to go by.

Sunset Avenue Keeps Its Food Counters

The closing leaves a dark storefront in the middle of a strip that will keep selling food. Two independent shops sit just a few doors from 70 Sunset.

Sunset Court Deli at 60 Sunset Avenue, known locally as the German Deli, does deli sandwiches, salads, dinner foods, takeout, and catering.

Justin's Chop Shop at 71 Sunset Avenue, across the street, sells meat, fresh fish, sandwiches, prepared foods, and pantry goods.

Together they cover a good share of what a dinner run needs: protein, prepared sides, and a few pantry staples. Neither one is set up to replace a 29,000-square-foot store's paper goods aisle or bulk produce section.

A short drive from there, Citarella at 141 Montauk Highway opened on April 30, 2026. The Citarella store page lists seafood, meat, prepared food, sushi, bakery, produce, and cheese departments. It's the closest thing in the village to a full set of departments under one roof. Newsday calls it a specialty upscale retailer and notes the Manhattan-based company runs three other Hamptons markets. The opening announcement gave hours of 6 a.m. to 8 p.m. The current listing says 7 a.m. to 7:30 p.m. daily. Since that has already changed once, check before heading over early or late. The company hasn't said publicly whether those hours will hold through the winter.

On and near Main Street, Goldberg's Famous Deli & Bagels at 65 Main Street carries bagels, sandwiches, deli meats and cheeses, smoked fish, and prepared salads. Mill Road Cheese Shop at 216 Mill Road sells artisanal cheeses, meats, and pantry goods.

The Weekly Cart Moves to the Highway

Once October 11 passes, the closest full-service supermarkets are outside the village. Here they are:

  • King Kullen, 52 E. Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
  • King Kullen, 25 Eastport Manor Road, Eastport
  • Stop & Shop, 194 West Montauk Highway, Hampton Bays
  • Stop & Shop, 167 Main Street, Southampton

Your best option depends on which side of the village you live on. Quiogue and Westhampton households heading east will reach the Hampton Bays stores. Remsenburg and Speonk households heading west will reach Eastport. With a full-service supermarket promised for Sunset Avenue but no date announced, these four stores will handle the big weekly shop for an open-ended stretch.

The Saturday Market Doesn't Stop

This is the part of the food calendar that runs longest. The Westhampton Beach Farmers Market brings together more than 60 vendors selling produce, fish, eggs, dairy, baked goods, and other local foods. Its outdoor Village Green dates run later into the year than many people assume:

  • Saturday, October 10, Village Green, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m., the day before Lidl closes
  • Saturday, November 21, Village Green, 9 a.m. to 1 p.m.
  • Saturdays, November 28 to December 26, the Holiday & Winter Market at St. Mark's Episcopal Church, 40 Main Street, 9 a.m. to 2 p.m.
  • Saturdays through April 24, 2027, the farmers' winter market continues, according to the same Chamber listing

For produce on other days, Schmitt's Farmstand at 76 Montauk Highway in Westhampton lists daily hours and a season that runs from April through December. Pumpkins are on its fall list now.

Put together, the village has fresh produce, fish, eggs, and baked goods on a weekly schedule all winter. What it won't have for a while is one parking lot where you can get all of that plus detergent and paper towels in a single stop. That's the gap 70 Sunset Avenue filled under four different names. Staller says a fifth grocer is coming.

What fills a 29,000-square-foot supermarket building affects the daily routine of a year-round Westhampton Beach home more than almost anything on a listing sheet. If you're thinking about how a fifth grocer at 70 Sunset Avenue could change errands, foot traffic, or demand on your street, Monica Reiner is following it as the news comes out. Schedule a private consultation with Monica to talk through what the change means for your property.

Work With Monica

When you choose Monica Reiner as your real estate broker, you can be confident that you have a seasoned professional on your side, dedicated to achieving your goals and surpassing your expectations. Contact Monica today to embark on your real estate journey.