November 12, 2026
"Why doesn't Sag Harbor own the holiday here?" Susie Franklin, proprietor of the American Hotel, put that question to friends and village stakeholders this year, as she told the Sag Harbor Express. The answers were not encouraging. According to Franklin, people told her the village had let most of its holiday traditions go, except for the tree lighting.
The first "Let's Holiday in Sag Harbor" is her committee's response. It starts around Thanksgiving and runs through the end of the year. It lands during a busy winter downtown. Crews have begun rebuilding the municipal dock and a harbor boardwalk, work the village deliberately put in the off-season. At Village Hall, a consultant has proposed keeping chain retailers off Main and Madison Streets and has pointed to the year-round economy as one reason. The tree lighting, the Santa visit and the construction staging are all on the harbor end of the village.
Franklin's committee is mostly local business owners and partners. It includes Tia Greene of Liebe PR, Penny Siebert of Brand Harbor, Mark Lubell, executive director of the Sag Harbor Cinema, Marilyn Holstein, president of the Sag Harbor Chamber of Commerce, local restaurant owner Jesse Matsuoka, and Polly Kruse, a longtime corporate event planner and friend of Franklin's from Denver.
They are asking businesses for very little. Franklin said the committee would go to every business in the village around Thanksgiving and ask them to put white lights in their windows. Beyond that, each shop decides how to decorate its own front. "Main Street is going to glow; it will shine like it never has before," she said. Temple Adas Israel was invited to take part and will put white lights on the temple too.
The Sag Harbor Chamber of Commerce lists the lights as running November 29 through December 31, 2026. Its description calls them a single continuous thread connecting the village's shops, restaurants, galleries and businesses.
Most of the season happens within a short walk of the harbor. Here is the run of dated events from publish day through mid-December:
| Date | Event | Where |
|---|---|---|
| Through Nov. 29 | To Kill a Mockingbird | Bay Street Theater |
| Nov. 24, 8 p.m. | "Think You're Funny? Graduation Show" | Bay Street Theater |
| Starting Nov. 25 | Annual Patrons' Art Show | John Jermain Memorial Library |
| Nov. 28–29, 11 a.m.–4 p.m. | Sixth annual Holiday Makers Market, 20-plus local makers | The Church, 48 Madison Street |
| Nov. 28, 4:15 p.m. | Light Up the Harbor, tree lit at about 5 p.m. | Long Wharf, Bay Street Theater courtyard |
| Nov. 29–Dec. 31 | Let's Holiday white lights | Village-wide |
| Dec. 5, 5–7 p.m. | Annual Holiday Party with live music and refreshments | Sag Harbor Whaling and Historical Museum |
| Dec. 12, 1–3 p.m. | Santa and Mrs. Claus visit | The Windmill and Long Wharf |
| Dec. 15, 4–8 p.m. | Let's Holiday main evening | Municipal Building steps, Main Street |
Light Up the Harbor is the one tradition Franklin's sources said had survived, and it is the first of the Chamber's three holiday listings, a day before the white lights begin. According to the Chamber's listing, festivities start at 4:15 p.m. on Long Wharf at the Bay Street Theater courtyard, the tree is lit at about 5 p.m., and the music ends at 5:30 p.m. It falls on the same Saturday as the first day of the Makers Market on Madison Street, so the afternoon can start at The Church and finish at the water.
For the Santa Visit on December 12, people meet at the Windmill to welcome Santa and Mrs. Claus to Long Wharf. Mrs. Claus rides down Main Street courtesy of the Sag Harbor Fire Department, and the Windmill has visits and photo opportunities from 1 to 3 p.m.
The committee picked its main date for a specific reason. On December 15 last year, a large crowd gathered outside the American Hotel and sang Irving Berlin's "White Christmas," the Express reported. This year the evening moves to the steps of the Municipal Building on Main Street, which Franklin said will "kind of be our stage."
From 4 to 8 p.m., chorus and band students from Sag Harbor Elementary School and Pierson Middle High School will perform, a group of children from Temple Adas Israel will sing Hanukkah songs, and the Eastville AME Zion Church will bring a gospel choir. At 7:40 p.m., Roman Roth of Wölffer Estate Vineyard will bring the choir from Christ Episcopal Church in Sag Harbor to sing "White Christmas" again.
Other parts of the program run before and after that night:
When the tree is lit on Long Wharf on November 28, the harbor just beyond it will already be under construction. The village planned it that way. As the Express reported, construction has begun on two long-awaited downtown waterfront projects. The village scheduled both for late fall and winter to keep disruption to marina operations, nearby businesses and downtown low during the summer season.
The first is the municipal "A" Dock at 11 West Water Street, just west of The Beacon. It is a T-shaped dock with 20 slips that has not been upgraded since it was built in the 1970s. It is being replaced with a floating dock, a new bulkhead, and a new boardwalk and catwalk.
The second is a new boardwalk from Windmill Beach, under the bridge, to Steinbeck Park Beach. It is designed to give people a safe way to walk between Windmill Beach, Steinbeck Park and the dock area. Preparatory work at Windmill Beach includes the Department of Public Works removing the existing benches, TB Tree Care doing tree work, and Diversified Services excavating the site so Chesterfield can start building. Ed Hollander coordinated that preparatory work, and the firms are doing it pro bono.
The construction will be visible through the holiday season. The village has said equipment and materials will be staged in designated areas near A Dock and that temporary parking restrictions may be needed. The village also posted a construction update for residents on November 9. The goal is to have both projects finished by late spring and open to the public before Memorial Day.
The Sag Harbor Partnership has committed $250,000 toward the boardwalk, and Ed Hollander will formally present the check to the Village Board of Trustees at its December 8 meeting. That is one week before the Main Street evening. In May, the same nonprofit honored Franklin at the American Hotel for taking over operations there.
The white-light program asks Main Street merchants to light up their windows in December. Separately, the village board is considering a rule about which kinds of businesses can occupy those storefronts.
In early November, the Express reported that environmental planning consultant Rich Warren of Inter-Science presented options for regulating formula and chain retail to a standing-room-only workshop at Village Hall. He recommended that the village define what a formula business is and create an exclusion overlay district barring chain retailers from Main Street and Madison Street. Formula businesses outside that core would need a special permit.
Warren's case was built partly on what happens to storefronts in the off-season. He told the board he had seen more seasonal shuttering in winter in neighboring village centers where chain stores have spread, and he argued that the hybrid approach would let officials ask applicants how they would support the year-round economy.
The draft map did not include Long Island Avenue, Long Wharf or Bay Street, and several attendees urged the board to extend the district to those waterfront corridors.
Long Wharf, where the tree is lit and where Santa and Mrs. Claus are welcomed, falls outside that draft district. The board was scheduled to take up the plan again on November 10.
The redevelopment proposal for 2 Main Street and 22 Long Island Avenue is one of the parcels left outside that draft map. 2 Main Street is the building known locally as Fort Apache, and 22 Long Island Avenue was formerly home to a 7-Eleven. According to The East Hampton Star, owner Mavik Capital has proposed replacing both buildings with two connected two-story buildings, a walkway and partly underground parking. The plan includes retail shops, restaurants, offices, a dry cleaner and a general store, and the owners said they were "working hard to retain all the current tenants."
The Planning Board held a public hearing on the preliminary site plan on October 27, the Star reported. The plan would raise the Main Street building to meet FEMA guidelines with parking underneath. It also needs a variance from the zoning board of appeals, because the village's superstore rule limits buildings to 10,000 square feet. Planning board members focused on the size of the building and on how the street would feel to someone walking by in the waterfront district, where the board chairman said harbor views are taken "very seriously."
Tenants spoke at the hearing too. Jesse Matsuoka, an owner of K Pasa and of Cruust, a sandwich shop that opened in the building this year, said the new owners are committed to building something that fits the neighborhood and the tenants. Matsuoka also sits on Franklin's holiday committee.
Some turnover elsewhere on Main Street is staying in local hands. Owner Kevin Menard told the Express that Dragon Hemp Apothecary plans to close before the end of the year and that his next venture, Toad, will open in January selling mushroom-and-herb wellness products.
The simplest way to see the season is to start at the Bay Street Theater courtyard at 4:15 p.m. on November 28, walk up Main Street under the white lights, and come back on December 15 for "White Christmas" on the Municipal Building steps at 7:40 p.m.
If you're thinking about what a home near the harbor means while A Dock and the new boardwalk are under construction, or once they open, Monica Reiner is glad to talk it through. Schedule a private consultation with Monica.
Stay up to date on the latest real estate trends.
Florida Lifestyle - Second Homes & Seasonal Living - Relocation
Finding Your Florida Winter Lifestyle
When you choose Monica Reiner as your real estate broker, you can be confident that you have a seasoned professional on your side, dedicated to achieving your goals and surpassing your expectations. Contact Monica today to embark on your real estate journey.